A featured contribution from Leadership Perspectives: a curated forum reserved for leaders nominated by our subscribers and vetted by the Education Technology Insights Advisory Board.

The Ohio State University

The Human Expertise behind Educational Innovation

Tracey Stuckey

Turning Creative Ideas into Meaningful Learning Experiences

There is a lot of space for meaningful educational innovation in instructional design. First, let’s define “meaningful educational innovation.” My favorite definition of innovation is by Sir Ken Robinson: “Innovation is applied creativity,” specifically, “the process of putting new ideas into practice.” Its intention is also to benefit society, so it is inherently meaningful.

I see instructional design as the application of the science of learning and the art of problem-solving to create optimal learning experiences. Therefore, the consummate instructional designer is always looking for evidence-influenced, creative ideas to put into practice. That is innovation: the ability to solve educational problems and make learning more effective. In my world, innovation is always about solving real problems for real people in new or different ways.

The Human Expertise behind AI-Powered Instructional Design

GenAI is one such tool that has everyone doing things differently. It has already shaken up instructional design. Just a few years ago, I debated with my students about using GenAI for course projects. Keeping an open mind, I did not want to discourage its use, yet I often asked them, “okay, if you have GenAI do the work, then what is your mind doing?” Well, today I have an answer: critique, revise, implement and evaluate.

Some of our favorite authoring tools, such as articulate storyline, now integrate GenAI, making instructional material creation much easier. Undoubtedly, some people think instructional designers are no longer needed because the software handles the basic work of instructional content creation. However, GenAI cannot yet decide whether content suits specific audiences, settings and instructional problems. It cannot critically evaluate the implementation of that content and determine ROI. Nor can it navigate the nuanced space of human performance improvement, where professionals must observe people at work in multifaceted, complex environments.

I remember learning web design and how to code webpages in HTML and JavaScript. Soon after, a favorite WYSIWYG editor hit the scene: Dreamweaver. It seemed that nearly anyone could code a webpage with this tool, or so we thought. It turned out that those who knew how to code and understood effective web design benefited most. Just look at some of the websites created by people who use a WYSIWYG editor without the necessary background expertise, and you will see why other considerations matter. I see a parallel between those considerations and the ones instructional designers must keep in mind when they use GenAI.

The Principles of Responsible GenAI Adoption

It is not a question of whether instructional designers will use GenAI but when. Most are already using it. I suggest some basic guidelines to help us make the most of it in our work.

1. Take an AI literacy course ASAP. Understanding this tool is the first step to using it well.

"In my world, innovation is always about solving real problems for real people in new or different ways.”

2. Know your stuff. An instructional designer's area of expertise focuses on psychology applied to learning and teaching, adult learning principles, learning experience design, technology integration, assessment and evaluation and performance improvement. Instructional designers must rely on their evidence-based expertise to evaluate GenAI output, its usefulness and its appropriateness for target learners and contexts.

3. Honor ethical principles when using GenAI. Intellectual property rights matter. Respect those rights and stay abreast of IP law relevant to our work. Always be transparent about the use of GenAI in your work. There is nothing to be ashamed of, but if your institution has policies against its use, honor those policies (but perhaps work to get them changed!).

4. Double-check GenAI output. It cannot do everything well, and we should not expect it to. Always critically review and edit its output.

5. Use GenAI to streamline your work, not replace you. Think of GenAI as your assistant, not your clone.

6. Be a confident and outspoken evaluator. Hone your ability to make critical, evaluative judgments and share them with clients and other stakeholders. Make it clear that your value lies in using your expertise to provide guidance.

This is not an exhaustive list, but these steps will help instructional designers use GenAI effectively and create learning experiences that reflect sound design principles.

Putting Pedagogy before Technology

Instructional designers are not the only ones who must uphold sound instructional design principles. Institutions must do the same. With all the bells and whistles, organizational leaders can shift their focus toward the tool and away from what science tells us about learning.

One way to avoid that drift is to form decision-making teams that include instructional designers in discussions about tool adoption. I have been known to say that no matter what tool is in use, “good teaching is good teaching,” and science tells us what that looks like. When a tool supports evidence-based instructional practice, everyone wins.

Build Expertise, Embrace Change and Keep Learning

We can all succeed if we grow, honor and use our expertise to its fullest potential. I know I make it sound easy, but of course, it is not. We live in a rapidly changing world, and we must navigate the shifting landscape while learning about it. For those who want to grow, I offer three actions that have helped me over the years:

1. Stay flexible and open to change, yet honor your principles. I have found that a professional go with the flow attitude is helpful, but this does not mean anything goes. As a professional, this means thinking carefully about change and how you can contribute to positive outcomes rather than resisting it blindly out of discomfort. Change always brings gains and losses. If it is change, we cannot control, we can focus on the gains and find ways to honor our professional principles within the outcomes of that change.

2. Do not believe the hype about technology tools such as GenAI making your job obsolete. Disruptive technology will likely change what you do or how you do it, thus moving you to follow the first action on this list: stay flexible. Your job may look and feel different, but it will likely remain. However, if the work changes so much that you no longer enjoy it, be bold and consider a professional shift. You likely have more transferable skills than you realize. Use them broadly. Identify where they transfer to other industries and consider areas of interest where you can grow.

3. Find ways to stay abreast of current trends and research in the field. Through professional organizations, trade publications, scholarly journals or your favorite instructional design content creator on LinkedIn or YouTube, we must keep learning and growing. I recommend a mix of channels to stay aware of research and emerging trends. This can also help with the second action on this list. If you are reading this right now, you are on the right track.

The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.

Weekly Brief